Can becoming the neighborhood expert help you build a real estate business that generates consistent referrals? On this episode of Why Do I Suck as a Real Estate Agent, I talked with Jeff Goodman of Brown Harris Stevens, a fourth-generation New Yorker and host of Rediscovering New York. Drawing on 22 years in advertising, he shared how walking tours, local history, networking, and video built his brand.
Quick takeaway: Pick a place you are passionate about, stay visible, and let local content bring the referrals.
From 22 Years in Advertising to New York Real Estate
Jeff spent 22 years in advertising, starting in media and direct mail, then moving into digital in 1996. In his mid-40s, he says, it got harder to find good opportunities, because managers were hiring younger people. So he explored other careers, and real estate came up.
He joked that if he had known what it would take, he would not have gone into it. He also would not have built the brand he has. His parents were landlords, so he knew real estate, but he learned that facilitating other people's transactions is a different business. His marketing background helped him build his own brand. It took four or five years before he really established it.
Hyperlocal Real Estate Marketing: Become the Neighborhood Expert
I asked Brown Harris Stevens agent Jeff Goodman why he niched into local history. Jeff said it happened by chance. At a networking event about 15 years ago, he met a walking tour company owner. He wondered what it would be like if an agent ran a regular walking tour series.
He compared it to an insurance company that aligned its brand behind wildlife conservation. He wanted to brand himself as the multi-neighborhood expert, passionate about the city and a link between people and its neighborhoods. As far as he knows, no other broker in the city does this.
Neighborhood Walking Tours: A Two-Act Referral Engine
His tours have two parts. In the first, the group walks a neighborhood. In the second, everyone goes to a local bar or restaurant. Sponsors cover snacks, and guests buy their own drinks. They sit, socialize, and connect. Jeff hosts, and a professional tour guide leads the walking portion.

I asked how this turns into sales. His answer was visibility with his sphere of influence.
"I get between 60 and 80 people on a tour. I have 4,600 people on my mailing list. And I really believe that the benefit of my having this event series probably gets me more leverage with people who don't come on my walking tours. The people who know me, who know my commitment to New York real estate, I have an open rate for my tour invitations of more than 50%. For a mailing list of 4,600, that's almost unheard of. And so people who don't come on my tours refer people to me. People who come on my tours refer people to me. So it's just keeping myself front and center in a way that brands me as being someone who's passionate about the city, connected to the city, loves to promote it."
His tours are by invitation only, and he does not advertise them.

Content Is the Linchpin: Email, Video, and Networking
Jeff Goodman, New York City agent with Brown Harris Stevens, says the content is the linchpin. The neighborhood comes first, and email, video, networking, and events come out of it. He produces short neighborhood videos for his YouTube channel, but his biggest audience is his own network, when he sends them out.
One client story shows how it works. Jeff had a listing in a mansion designed by Stanford White. A couple who had come on his walking tours saw the video, bought the duplex, and later used him to sell their two properties. They have also referred other clients. His point is simple: we are in a people business.

Why a Whole City Is Not One Market
I asked if you can treat New York as one market. Jeff says no. The city covers 300 square miles and has 8.5 million people. Even in one neighborhood, you can have different segments.
"Sometimes people say to me, how's the market? I go, which one? [...] Even in Manhattan you have variables: neighborhood, cooperative versus condominium, studio, one-bedroom, two-bedroom, what kind of amenities does a building have. So all those variables, the relationship of the potential buyers, the number of potential buyers for those relative to the supply is not always the same. So we have market segments that don't always move in tandem."
He sells everything from a walk-up with a private roof deck to townhouses. That is why choosing a niche matters.
Hyperlocal Marketing in Smaller Markets
I live in Green Bay, where you can drive anywhere in 15 minutes. I asked how this applies to an agent in a small Midwestern town. Jeff says to find something you are passionate about that connects you to the community.
"What can apply to them is figuring out something that you're passionate about that connects you with the business and connects you with things in the community and to be public and herald about it and to get out and meet people. The key things to me are being passionate about what you do, about being visible, and having enough of a connection of things that people in the market care about, where they look upon you as someone who's committed to the area, who's committed to them."
Building a Real Estate Referral Network as a New Agent
I asked what a new agent should do first. Jeff says you have to know people.
- Reach out to the people you know and tell them what you are doing and why.
- Show you are committed and aligned with a company that has good managers and resources.
- Ask for referrals gently. For example, ask them to keep you in mind if someone they know is making a change.
- Be a resource about your market.
Getting Around Manhattan and Staying Resilient
Jeff does showings by subway and bus. Crosstown trips can take 12 minutes, and he can check email on the way. He is also confident about the city's future, calling New York the island at the center of the world.
Refresh Your Brand, Use AI, and Keep Calling
You cannot just be established, Jeff warns. Some agents who started before him saw their businesses dry up when they did not adapt. He tries to refresh his brand, and he admits he should call his network more often.
He also says to try new things. He spent several thousand dollars on a public relations effort that did not work, but he is not sorry. He says AI has helped people find him, and he has been working on showing up there.
Frequently Asked Questions About Hyperlocal Real Estate Marketing
How can agents generate referrals without chasing leads?
Build visibility and trust through neighborhood content, events, email, and community involvement.
Why should agents focus on specific neighborhoods?
Areas differ in property types, price points, buyers, and supply and demand.
How can new agents build a first referral network?
Reconnect with people you know, share your commitment, and ask them to keep you in mind.
How do walking tours generate business?
They position you as a local expert, help you meet people, and keep you visible.
Connect With Jeff Goodman and Monte Reyment
Visit Jeff's website or find him on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn. To follow my work, visit Take Action Realty Group or find me on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn. Thank you to Jeff Goodman of Brown Harris Stevens. Remember, you don't suck. You're learning.
Apply to Be a Guest on the Why Do I Suck as a Real Estate Agent Podcast
The people on this show are not guessing. They are sharing habits and systems that work. If you have been doing the work and can help other agents, I'd love to hear from you.
This podcast is produced by the Icons of Real Estate - #1 Real Estate Podcast Network. If you are a real estate professional, apply to be a guest speaker across the network.



